SWAMI VIVEKANANDA J K SIVAN

SWAMI VIVEKANANDA  –   nanganallur  J K SIVAN
UNDERSTAND  ‘ BHAGAVATH GITA”

It is a part of the epic Mahâbhârata. To understand the Gita properly, several things are very important to know. Is it a part of Mahabaratha? Did Veda Vyasa write it?  or is it an interpolation ?   Was there  Krishna the great  historical personality?  Did a war take place at Kurukshethra? Were there really the historical persons such as  Bheema, or Arjuna?
There are more than one who went by the name  Veda Vyasa in Hindu scriptures. If so who was the real author of the Gita — the Bâdarâyana Vyasa or Dvaipâyana Vyasa? beause “Vyasa” was only a title. Anyone who composed a new Purâna was known by the name of Vyasa, like the word Vikramâditya, which was also a general name. ]
Another point is, Gita, had not been much known to the generality of people before Shankarâchârya made it famous by writing his great commentary on it. Long before that, there was   the commentary on it by Bodhâyana. Bodhayana Bhâshya on the Vedânta Sutras — from which Râmânuja compiled his Shri-Bhâshya, which Shankaracharya mentions and even quotes in part here and there in his own commentary, and which was so greatly discussed by the Swami Dayânanda . I  could not get a copy of  Bodhayana Bhashya  in spite of my travels.  Ramanuja compiled his Bhashya from a worm-eaten manuscript which he happened to find. When even this great Bodhayana Bhashya on the Vedanta-Sutras is so much enshrouded in the darkness of uncertainty, it is simply useless to try to establish the existence of the Bodhayana Bhashya on the Gita. Some say Adi Sankara wrote Gita and interpolated in Mahabharatha, but no evidence or proof  for this.

Chhândogya Upanishad mentions Krishna, the son of Devaki, who received spiritual instructions from one Ghora, a Yogi. In the Mahabharata, Krishna is the king of Dwârakâ; and in the Vishnu Purâna we find a description of Krishna playing with the Gopis. Again, in the Bhâgavata, the account of his Râsalilâ is detailed at length. In very ancient times in our country there was in vogue an Utsava called Madanotsava (celebration in honour of Cupid). That very thing was transformed into Dola and thrust upon the shoulders of Krishna. Who can be so bold as to assert that the Rasalila and other things connected with him were not similarly fastened upon him? In ancient times there was very little tendency in our country to find out truths by historical research. So any one could say what he thought best without substantiating it with proper facts and evidence.In ancient times there was very little hankering after name and fame in men. So it often happened that one man composed a book and made it pass current in the name of his Guru or of someone else. In such cases it is very hazardous for the investigator of historical facts to get at the truth. In those days, they had no knowledge whatever of geography. So imagination ran riot. And so we meet with such fantastic creations of the brain as sweet-ocean, milk-ocean, clarified-butter-ocean, curd-ocean, etc! In the Puranas, we find one living ten thousand years, another a hundred thousand years! But the Vedas say, शतायुर्वै पुरुषः — “Man lives a hundred years.” Whom shall we follow here? So, to reach a correct conclusion in the case of Krishna is well-nigh impossible.
It is human nature to build round the real character of a great man,  all sorts of imaginary superhuman attributes. As regards Krishna the same must have happened, but it seems quite probable that he was a king. Quite probable I say, because in ancient times it was chiefly the kings who exerted themselves most in the preaching of Brahma-Jnâna. Another point to be especially noted here is that whoever might have been the author of the Gita, we find its teachings the same as those in the whole of the Mahabharata. From this we can safely infer that in the age of the Mahabharata some great man arose and preached the Brahma-Jnâna in this new garb to the then existing society. Another fact comes to the fore that in the olden days, as one sect after another arose, there also came into existence and use among them one new scripture or another. It happened, too, that in the lapse of time both the sect and its scripture died out, or the sect ceased to exist but its scripture remained. Similarly, it was quite probable that the Gita was the scripture of such a sect which had embodied its high and noble ideas in this sacred book.

As for the Kurukshetra War, no special evidence in support of it can be adduced. But there is no doubt that there was a war fought between the Kurus and the Panchâlas.   How could there be so much discussion about Jnâna, Bhakti, and Yoga on the battle-field, where the huge army stood in battle array ready to fight, just waiting for the last signal? Was there  any shorthand writer at the battle fiield to take down  every word spoken between Krishna and Arjuna, in the din and turmoil of the battle-field?  Some say the  Kurukshetra War is only an allegory. When we sum up its esoteric significance, it means the war which is constantly going on within man between the tendencies of good and evil. This meaning, too, may not be irrational.
Regarding the historicity of  Arjuna and others,  ‘Shatapatha Brâhmana ‘ the very ancient book mentions somewhere all the names of those who were the performers of the Ashvamedha Yajna: but there is no mention of the names of Arjuna and others, though it speaks of Janamejaya, the son of Parikshit who was a grandson of Arjuna. The Mahabharata and other books  state Yudhishthira, Arjuna, and others who celebrated the Ashvamedha sacrifice.

One thing should be remembered. Even if  historicity of the whole thing is proved to be absolutely false, it will not in the least be any loss to us  because  we have  to get at the truth; we should not be  bound by wrong ideas born of ignorance.  People  do not think  of the importance of such inquiries. Many believe that while preaching  a good thing  beneficial, there is no harm in telling an untruth. Hence we find many of our Tantras beginning with, “Mahâdeva said to Pârvati”. But our duty should be to convince ourselves of the truth, to believe in truth only.  You have to keep your eye always fixed on truth only and shun all superstitions completely.

What is there in  Gita? It is an  introduction of the discussion of a great truth,  the Gita is like a fine garland or a bouquet of the choicest flowers containig various Upanishadhic  truths.  Gita is the subject of Bhakti different  from all preceding scriptures?  Though before its advent, Yoga, Jnana, Bhakti, etc. had each its strong adherents, they all quarrelled among themselves, each claiming superiority for his own chosen path; no one ever tried to seek for reconciliation among these different paths. It was the author of the Gita who for the first time tried to harmonise these. He took the best from what all the sects then existing had to offer and threaded them in the Gita.
Nishkâma Karma  means work without desire or attachment. People nowadays understand what is meant by this in various ways. Some say what is implied by being unattached is to become purposeless. If that were its real meaning, then heartless brutes and the walls would be the best exponents of the performance of Nishkama Karma. Many others, again, give the example of Janaka, and wish themselves to be equally recognised as past masters in the practice of Nishkama Karma! Janaka (lit. father) did not acquire that distinction by bringing forth children, but these people all want to be Janakas, with the sole qualification of being the fathers of a brood of children! No! The true Nishkama Karmi (performer of work without desire) is neither to be like a brute, nor to be inert, nor heartless. He is not Tâmasika but of pure Sattva. His heart is so full of love and sympathy that he can embrace the whole world with his love. The world at large cannot generally comprehend his all-embracing love and sympathy.
The reconciliation of the different paths of Dharma, and work without desire or attachment — these are the two special characteristics of the Gita.

Disclaimer
This blog is dedicated to the study, appreciation, and devotional exploration of Indian deities, traditions, and spiritual practices. All content published here is intended solely for educational, informational, and research purposes.

The views, interpretations, and information presented reflect personal understanding and publicly available sources, and are not intended to offend or misrepresent any religion, community, sect, or belief system. Readers are encouraged to consult authoritative scriptures, scholars, and religious authorities for definitive guidance.

Copyright & Intellectual Property: Images, texts, quotations, and other materials featured on this blog may be the property of their respective owners. Such materials are used in good faith for non-commercial, educational, and illustrative purposes under the principle of fair use/fair dealing. No copyright infringement is intended. If you are the rightful owner of any content displayed here and believe it has been used improperly, please contact us and the material will be promptly removed or duly credited.

No Liability: While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the author makes no warranties regarding the completeness or reliability of the information. Any reliance you place on such information is strictly at your own risk.

All trademarks, logos, and brand names are the property of their respective owners.



Avatar photo
Krishnan Sivan

Sri J.K.Sivan, by profession is a specialist consultant in Marine Insurance, having been a top executive in International Shipowning Organisations abroad, besides being a good singer, a team leader in spiritual activities, social activist, and organised pilgrimage to various temples in the South covering about 5000 temples, interested more in renovating neglected, dilapidated ancient temples He resides in Chennai at Nanganallur.

Articles: 2561

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

;